So during vacation I've decided to find a different insurer and came across Pet Insurance Review that has a large list comparing the pet insurance companies and their level of policy coverage and a quick and easy way to compare policies- I actually received 4 quotes while I was writing this!
Trupanion has a great explanation of typical definitions used in policies so you know what to expect as you start to compare offers and look at deductibles. Look for discounts for multiple pets and online registration. Beware of age and pre-existing condition limitations, we need coverage for congenital diseases and not many offer that. Do your homework, I wish I would have done more the first time!